This course syllabus is discontinued or replaced by a new course syllabus.

Logotype Örebro universitet

School of Behavioural, Social and Legal Sciences

Course Syllabus


Comparative and Foreign Law: The Origins, Today's World and the Future, 30 Credits


Course Code: RV200G Subject Area: Field of Law
Main Field of Study: Law Credits: 30
    Subject Group (SCB): Law and Legal Studies
Education Cycle: First Cycle Progression: G1F
Established: 2014-12-12 Last Approved: 2018-10-01
Valid from: Spring semester 2019 Approved by: Head of School


Aims and Objectives

General aims for first cycle education

First-cycle courses and study programmes shall develop:
- the ability of students to make independent and critical assessments
- the ability of students to identify, formulate and solve problems autonomously, and
- the preparedness of students to deal with changes in working life.

In addition to knowledge and skills in their field of study, students shall develop the ability to:
- gather and interpret information at a scholarly level
- stay abreast of the development of knowledge, and
- communicate their knowledge to others, including those who lack specialist knowledge in the field.

(Higher Education Act, Chapter 1, Section 8)

Course Objectives

At the completion of the course the students shall be able to demonstrate a critical approach and reasoning toward questions concerning the role of comparative law in a world of cultural and religious diversity, and of dynamic legal development under the influence of Europeanization, Americanization and globalization.

Learning goals for sub-course 1: The Western Legal Tradition, 12 ECTS credits
At the completion of the sub-course the students should exhibit:
- Basic knowledge of the functions of comparative law,
- Basic knowledge of the different legal systems and their groupings into so-called "legal families",
- Knowledge of how the Western legal systems have developed historically, with particular reference to the history of French, German, English, US law, and Eastern Europe.
- Understanding of the fundamental differences between civil law, common law and the Scandinavian legal family, as regards legal sources, the role of the courts and other legal actors, and the relationship between the different branches of law.
- Understanding of the relationship between legal development and changes in the general culture.

Learning goals for sub-course 2: The Legal Development beyond Europe, 7,5 ECTS credits
At the completion of the sub-course the students should exhibit:
- Basic knowledge of certain religious legal systems such as the Islamic, the Hindu, and the Jewish systems,
- Understanding of the relationship between Western (colonial) legal systems and local customary traditions in Africa,
- Basic knowledge of the legal development in Asia, especially in India, China and Japan,
- Basic knowledge of the subject legal anthropology, its scientific goals, methods and development,
- Understanding of the distinctive features of the Western legal tradition

Learning goals for sub-course 3: Independent Comparative Studies, 4.5 ECTS credits
At the completion of the sub-course the students should exhibit:
- In-depth understanding of theoretical and methodological problems related to studies of foreign legal systems and comparative law,
- Ability to identify, formulate and analyze independently relevant comparative law problems,
- Capacity for an independent and critical approach to legal systems
- Ability to work individually and in collaboration with others (under supervision) to complete a comparative study, and to present and defend the results of the study both in written form and verbally at a final seminar, also displaying
- the ability to give constructive criticism and respond to such criticism with a foundation based on relevant legal scientific doctrine.

Learning goals for sub-course 4: Private International Law, 6 ECTS credits
- A good knowledge of private international law, including general principles, international jurisdiction, applicable law, and the effect of foreign judgments regarding private law matters, such as contracts, torts, marriages and divorces, and custody of children, respectively.
- Ability to independently apply the method of private international law.
- Ability to identify and relate a private international law problem to the relevant theories and legal framework of private international law.
- Ability to present a well-argued solution to a given private international law problem.
- An insight into comparative private international law, including a basic understanding of certain fundamental differences between the common law tradition and the civil law tradition regarding international jurisdiction, as well as between the European classic approach and the U.S. interest analysis approach regarding the applicable law.

Skills and ability
The students shall display an ability to find, evaluate and communicate relevant legal information from central foreign legal systems, also displaying the skills necessary to apply comparative legal theory and method in verbal argumentation and in written form. The goal of the course is also to offer a tool for a better understanding of and a critical perspective on their home legal system, with particular regard to the interaction between different legal sources.


Main Content of the Course

Sub-course 1. The Western Legal Tradition, 12 hp (12 ECTS credits):
The sub-course offers the student a view of the Western legal tradition. The main focus will be on the differences between the common law and civil law legal families. Legal sources and the role of the courts and other legal actors in the different systems are studied with particular attention. These topics will be treated in the context of the Scandinavian legal tradition as well. A discussion will also be held on whether the Scandinavian legal systems form their own legal family separated from the civil law tradition. Furthermore a foremost approach will also be taken toward discussing the French, German, English, and American legal traditions.

Sub-course 2. The Legal Development beyond Europe, 7,5 hp (7,5 ECTS credits):
This sub-course will deal with some of the most interesting non-European legal traditions. Focus will lie on religiously based legal traditions, such as the Islamic, Hindu and Hebrew legal systems, also considering the legal development within Africa and certain Asian countries such as Japan and China.
The sub-course will also give students some basic knowledge on the subject of legal anthropology. The course will especially analyze the relationship between the western (colonial) law, which is applied in the cities, and local customary law which is applied in the villages.
The sub-course will end with an open debate on what aspects characterize the western legal tradition in comparison to the rest of the world.

Sub-course 3. Independent Comparative Studies, 4.5 hp (4.5 ECTS credits)
In sub-course 3 the students will, under supervision, write two short memoranda, one individually and one in small groups, on the same topic in the area of comparative law. Group work will be based on the individual memoranda. Sub-course 3 will be introduced with lectures concerning comparative methodology, legal writing and legal English. The memoranda will be discussed orally at a specific seminar.

Sub-course 4. Private International Law, 6 hp (6 ECTS credits)
The main focus of the last sub-course is the EU-law on private international law, i.e. the Brussels I and Rome I and II Regulations within the field of civil and commercial law matters, and the Brussels II bis and Rome III Regulation as well as the Maintenance Regulation within the field of family law matters. The sub-course also deals with the interplay between the EU-rules and the autonomous rules of private international law of the Member States (remaining competence), in particular the Swedish rules on private international law.


Teaching Methods

The course is given in English.
The course consists of lectures, seminars and discussion panels. The objective is to supplement theoretical skills with exercises in both oral and written forms. There is mandatory attendance with respect to certain seminars. Students are expected to prepare for and actively participate in the different teaching moments.

Students who have been admitted to and registered on a course have the right to receive tuition and/or supervision for the duration of the time period specified for the particular course to which they were accepted (see, the university's admission regulations (in Swedish)). After that, the right to receive tuition and/or supervision expires.


Examination Methods

The Western Legal Tradition: Written Exam, 3 Credits. (Code: 0110)
Written Exam (max. 10 points).
The Western Legal Tradition: Oral exam, 9 Credits. (Code: 0120)
Oral Exam (max. 30 points).
The Western Legal Tradition (Code: 0130)
The results of the written and the oral exams are added in order to obtain the final grade for sub-course 1 (max. 40 points).
The Legal Development beyond Europe, 7.5 Credits. (Code: 0201)
Oral examination (max. 20 points).
Independent Comparative Studies: Individual Memorandum (Code: 0300)
Individual memorandum (max. 10 points).
Independent Comparative Studies: Group Work (Code: 0310)
Memorandum, Group work (max. 10 points).
Independent Comparative Studies: Oral Presentation (Code: 0320)
Oral presentation (max 6 points).
Independent Comparative Studies, 4.5 Credits. (Code: 0330)
The results of the individual memorandum, group work and the oral presentation are added in order to obtain the final grade for sub-course 3 (max. 26 points).
Private International Law: Written Exam, 4.5 Credits. (Code: 0400)
Written Exam (max. 14 points).
Private International Law: Individual Memorandum, 1.5 Credits. (Code: 0415)
Individual memorandum with oral presentation (max. 10 points).
Private International Law (Code: 0430)
The results of the written exam and the individual memorandum with oral presentation are added in order to obtain the final grade for sub-course 4 (max. 24 points).

For further information, see the university's local examination regulations (in Swedish).


Grades

According to the Higher Education Ordinance, Chapter 6, Section 18, a grade is to be awarded on the completion of a course, unless otherwise prescribed by the university. The university may prescribe which grading system shall apply. The grade is to be determined by a teacher specifically appointed by the university (an examiner).

According to regulations on grading systems for first- and second-cycle education (vice-chancellor's decision 2010-10-19, reg. no. CF 12-540/2010), one of the following grades is to be used: fail, pass, or pass with distinction. The vice-chancellor or a person appointed by the vice-chancellor may decide on exceptions from this provision for a specific course, if there are special reasons.

Grades used on course are Fail (U), Pass (G) or Pass with Distinction (VG).

The Western Legal Tradition: Written Exam
Grades used are Fail (U) or Pass (G).
The Western Legal Tradition: Oral exam
Grades used are Fail (U), Pass (G) or Pass with Distinction (VG).
The Western Legal Tradition
Grades used are Fail (U), Pass (G) or Pass with Distinction (VG).
The Legal Development beyond Europe
Grades used are Fail (U), Pass (G) or Pass with Distinction (VG).
Independent Comparative Studies: Individual Memorandum
Grades used are Fail (U) or Pass (G).
Independent Comparative Studies: Group Work
Grades used are Fail (U) or Pass (G).
Independent Comparative Studies: Oral Presentation
Grades used are Fail (U) or Pass (G).
Independent Comparative Studies
Grades used are Fail (U), Pass (G) or Pass with Distinction (VG).
Private International Law: Written Exam
Grades used are Fail (U) or Pass (G).
Private International Law: Individual Memorandum
Grades used are Fail (U) or Pass (G).
Private International Law
Grades used are Fail (U), Pass (G) or Pass with Distinction (VG).


Concerning the course in its entirety the students' results are evaluated through a system of points. The maximum level for the entire course is 110 points. Out of these the students can obtain:
- A maximum of 10 points from the written exam in sub-course 1.
- A maximum of 30 points from the oral examination in sub-course 1.
- A maximum of 20 points from the oral examination in sub-course 2.
- A maximum of 10 points from the individual memorandum in sub-course 3.
- A maximum of 10 points from the group work in sub-course 3.
- A maximum of 6 points from the oral presentation in sub-course 3.
- A maximum of 14 points from the written exam in private international law in sub-course 4.
- A maximum of 10 points from the individual memorandum with oral presentation in private international law in sub-course 4. The results from those eight examinations will be added in order to reach one of the following grades: U (Fail), G (Pass), and VG (Pass with distinction).

55 points are required to obtain the grade G. 83 points are required to obtain the grade VG. The student also has to have received at least
- 5 points from the written exam in sub-course 1,
- 15 points from the oral examination in sub-course 1,
- 10 points from the oral examination in sub-course 2,
- 13 points from the independent comparative studies in sub-course 3,
- 7 points from the written exam in sub-course 4,
- 5 points from the individual memorandum with oral presentation in sub-course 4.


For further information, see the university's local examination regulations (in Swedish).


Specific entry requirements

Basic Course in Law, 30 ECTS credits

For further information, see the university's admission regulations (in Swedish).


Transfer of Credits for Previous Studies

Students who have previously completed higher education or other activities are, in accordance with the Higher Education Ordinance, entitled to have these credited towards the current programme, providing that the previous studies or activities meet certain criteria.


For further information, see the university's local credit transfer regulations (in Swedish).


Other Provisions

Sub-course 3: The memoranda are to be handed in via Blackboard before the oral presentation seminar. Only students who handed in an individual memorandum can participate in the group work. Memoranda that obtain the grade Fail may be completed. In case of completion (komplettering) the student can only obtain a maximum of 19 points for sub-course 3 and, consequently, only the grade Fail (U) or Pass (G) can be awarded. The completed paper is to be re-submitted in August.

Sub-course 4: A memorandum that has been awarded the grade Fail may be completed to the grade Pass. In case of completion (komplettering) the student can only obtain a maximum of 5 credit points for the memorandum and, consequently, only the grade Fail (U) or Pass (G) can be awarded. The completed memorandum must be re-submitted no later than the last day of the re-sit period in August, failing that the grade Fail will be awarded and a replacement assignment must be submitted. The same applies if the completion is awarded the grade Fail.

For the examinations that are graded with Fail (U), Pass (G) or Pass with Distinction (VG), the following point limits apply:
- Sub-course 1: 20 points are required to obtain the grade Pass (G) and 30 points are required to obtain the grade Pass with Distinction (VG).
- Sub-course 2: 10 points are required to obtain the grade Pass (G) and 15 points are required to obtain the grade Pass with Distinction (VG).
- Sub-course 3: 13 points are required to obtain the grade Pass (G) and 20 points are required to obtain the grade Pass with Distinction (VG).
- Sub-course 4: 12 points are required to obtain the grade Pass (G) and 18 points are required to obtain the grade Pass with Distinction (VG).


Transitional Provisions

For a course that has been cancelled or significantly changed in content or scope, there may be examinations on three occasions within 12 to 18 months after the changes have been made.


Reading List and Other Teaching Materials

Part 1: Required Reading

Farnsworth, E. Allan (2010)/4 ed.
An Introduction to the Legal System of the United States
Oxford University Press, 248 pages
Giaro, Tomasz
Legal tradition of Eastern Europe. Its rise and demise (2011)
2 Comparative Law Review 1-23
Mattei, Ugo
Three Patterns of Law: Taxonomy and Change in the World's Legal Systems (1997)
45 American Journal of Comparative Law 5-44
Merryman, John H. (2007)/3rd ed.
The Civil Law Tradition
Stanford University Press, 160 pages
Samuel, Geoffrey (2013)
A Short Introduction to the Common Law
Edward Elgar Publ, 208 pages

Part 2: Required Reading
Blanc-Jouvan, Xavier
The Encounter Between Traditional Law and Modern Law in French-Speaking Africa: A Personal Reflection (2010)
25 Tulane Eur. & Civ. L.F. 197-209
Conley, J.M. - O'Barr, W.M.
Legal Anthropology Comes Home: Brief History of the Ethnographic Study of Law (1993-94)
27 Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review 41-64
Elon, Menachem
The Legal System of Jewish Law (1984-85)
17 N.Y.U. Journal of International Law and Politics 221-243
Hallaq, Wael B. (2009)
An Introduction to Islamic Law
Cambridge University Press, 200 pages
Merry, Sally Engle
Legal Pluralism (1988)
22 Law and Society Review 869-892
Peerenboom, Randall (2002)
China's Long March Towards Rule of Law, 27-49
Cambridge University Press
Rabin, Edward H.
The Evolution and Impact of Jewish Law: Foreword (1995)
1 U.C. Davis Journal of International Law and Policy 49-56
Rocher, Ludo
Hindu Conceptions of Law (1977-78)
29 Hastings Law Journal 1283-1305

Part 4: Required Reading
Briggs, Adrian (2013)
The Conflict of Laws
Oxford University Press, 448 pages, selected parts of approx. 300 pages


Additions and Comments on the Reading List

Sub-course 1:
Relevant cases for the case seminar will be listed on Blackboard at the beginning of the course.

Sub-course 3:
Materials, articles and references as posted on Blackboard. (max. 200 pages).

Sub-course 4:
Materials and case references as posted on Blackboard (max. 200 pages).

The latest edition of the literature should be used. If a later edition of course literature is available but is not listed above, use the later edition.


See this Course Syllabus as PDF